Is It Better to Sell or Rent Out Your Home?

Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh • May 13, 2024

Is It Better to Sell or Rent Out Your Home?

Deciding whether it is better to sell or rent out your home is a huge decision, both financially and personally. At Charlton Property Management, we understand that each option has benefits and challenges. As a part of our residential property management services, we help countless Kiwi families navigate this tough decision. 

 

This guide will help you understand the complexities of selling vs renting out your home, considering financial implications, market trends, and personal circumstances.


Financial Considerations


Potential Income vs. Immediate Returns

Renting out your property can generate a steady stream of passive income, which is particularly desirable in areas with strong rental demand and rates. However, carefully evaluating ongoing costs like maintenance, property management, and potential vacancies is crucial. 


On the other hand, selling may provide an immediate financial windfall, especially in a seller's market. This lump sum can be significant, allowing you to invest in other ventures or settle financial obligations.


Tax Implications

Both selling and renting out your property have different tax implications. Rental income is taxable, but you can also deduct expenses related to the rental, like repairs and property management services. Selling your home may result in capital gains tax if the property has appreciated in value since you purchased it. However, primary residences are often exempt from this tax up to a certain limit. 


It's always a good idea to consult a tax professional to understand how each option would impact your financial situation.


Long-term Financial Goals

Ultimately, your decision should align with long-term financial objectives. Keeping and renting the property out might be more beneficial if you aim for long-term wealth accumulation. However, if you need immediate liquidity or are looking to downsize your financial responsibilities, selling could be the more prudent path.


With Charlton's expertise backing your decision, we can help you choose the best option for your financial situation.



Market Trends


Real Estate Market Conditions

The current state of the real estate market in your area can significantly influence your decision to sell or rent. In a seller's market, where demand exceeds supply, you might secure a higher selling price. Conversely, in a buyer's market, where there's an abundance of properties available and fewer buyers, prices tend to be lower, and homes can linger on the market. In this scenario, renting out your property may be more beneficial until market conditions improve.

 

Rental Market Dynamics

Understanding the rental market is just as crucial. High vacancy rates could mean potential rental income is less reliable than you may have anticipated. A strong rental market with low vacancy rates and high demand could make renting out your home more attractive and profitable.


Personal Factors


Your Future Housing Needs

When considering what to do with your property, it's vital to reflect on your future plans and housing requirements. If you anticipate moving back or using the property, renting it out could preserve your home for later use. Selling your home is a more definitive action that leaves you without the property should your circumstances change.


Retirement Plans

As you plan for retirement, consider how your property fits into these plans. Many people view their property not just as a home but as a key component of their retirement strategy. If you envision returning to this home during your retirement years for its comfort or memories, retaining the property and renting it out in the interim could be beneficial.


Emotional Attachments

While financial factors often drive the decision to sell or rent out your home, the deeply personal element of homeownership cannot be ignored.

Sometimes, emotional attachments to the property can influence the decision to sell or rent. If parting with your family home is challenging, renting it out might be a more acceptable compromise until you are ready to let go.


Willingness to Manage a Rental Property

Being a landlord requires commitment. You'll need to manage tenants, maintenance issues, and legal responsibilities. Hiring a property management company like Charlton can alleviate the burden if you prefer not to handle these duties.


Charlton Can Help You Make the Right Decision

Whether it is better to sell or rent out your home is influenced by plenty of outside factors, but ultimately, it is up to you and your unique situation. At Charlton Property Management, we are here to provide expert advice and services whether you decide to sell your home or become a landlord. By understanding both paths, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your personal and financial objectives.


Choosing whether to sell or rent out your home is not a decision to be taken lightly. Contact us today for more in-depth advice and rental appraisals to help you make the best decision. 


By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh February 14, 2025
Market Trends & Demand In Kohi-tātea (January), there were 135,000 searches by potential tenants looking for properties in Epsom. While this is still a strong level of interest, it represents a 5% decrease compared to the same time last year. During this period, five new listings entered the market. The median expected rent price for a three-bedroom townhouse in Epsom is currently $905 per week, reflecting a 1% increase compared to last year. However, one of the most significant shifts is the median days on site, which has skyrocketed to 102 days, a 538% increase from the same period last year. This suggests that properties are taking significantly longer to rent out. Who’s Renting in Epsom? Epsom attracts a mix of young professionals and families. Recent data shows: 37.3% of renters in this area are under 30 years old. 25.4% are aged between 30 and 39. These demographics indicate a steady demand from working professionals and families looking for quality homes in a prime location. How the Unitary Plan is Shaping Epsom’s Rental Market With Auckland’s Unitary Plan pushing for higher-density developments, Epsom has seen an increase in townhouse availability over the past year. This growth in rental stock may be contributing to the longer time on the market for some properties. However, this intensification also benefits renters, providing modern, high-quality housing options in one of Auckland’s most desirable suburbs. 
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh February 10, 2025
For many renters in New Zealand, finding a pet-friendly home has been a long-standing challenge. With landlords hesitant to accept tenants with pets due to concerns about property damage, many pet owners have struggled to secure suitable accommodation. However, recent proposed amendments to the Residential Tenancies Act aim to balance the rights of tenants and landlords while ensuring more Kiwis can keep their beloved pets. What Are the Proposed Changes? The government has outlined several key reforms designed to make renting with pets easier while addressing landlords' concerns. These proposed changes include: 1. Pet Bonds Under the new rules, landlords will be able to request a pet bond of up to two weeks' rent in addition to the standard bond. This additional financial security is intended to cover any pet-related damages beyond normal wear and tear. 2. Tenant Liability for Pet Damage Tenants will be fully responsible for any damage caused by their pets . While this has always been a concern for landlords, the new changes clarify that tenants must cover all repairs for any pet-related damage, rather than relying on standard bond payments alone. 3. Landlord Consent for Pets Currently, many landlords impose a blanket "no pets" policy. The reforms propose that landlords cannot unreasonably refuse a tenant's request to have a pet . Instead, landlords must provide a valid reason if they deny permission. Acceptable grounds for refusal may include: Property size and suitability – For example, a large dog may not be appropriate in a small apartment. Lack of fencing or secure outdoor space – If a property cannot safely accommodate a pet, landlords may refuse. Allergy concerns in multi-unit dwellings – If other tenants have allergies, landlords may deny requests based on health concerns.  4. Encouraging More Pet-Friendly Rentals With these changes, New Zealand aims to create a more pet-friendly rental market. The goal is to encourage landlords to reconsider their stance on pets , knowing that they have greater financial security through pet bonds and clearly defined tenant responsibilities.
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh February 4, 2025
Mount Eden continues to be one of Auckland’s most desirable suburbs for renters, offering a blend of convenience, community, and charm . Whether you're a landlord looking to understand the market trends or a tenant searching for the perfect home, here’s what’s happening in the rental market for 3-bedroom homes in Mount Eden this fortnight.
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh January 15, 2025
With the summer school holidays coming to an end, it’s time for many families to return to a normal routine. This period also marks a busy time in the rental market, with plenty of tenant movement and landlords preparing their properties for the New Year rush. Whether you’re a landlord ensuring your investment property is ready for new tenants or a tenant settling back into a routine, now is the perfect time to take stock and get organised for the months ahead. Landlords: Gearing Up for the New Year Summer is peak season in the property management world, with increased demand for rentals and higher turnover. Here’s how landlords can stay on top of things: Prepare for Tenant Turnover : Summer often brings tenant changes as families settle before the school term. Make sure your property is in top shape to attract quality tenants quickly. This includes thorough cleaning, minor repairs, and ensuring all appliances are in working order. Inspect and Maintain : With the hotter weather, now is a good time to inspect air conditioning systems, check for water leaks, and ensure that outdoor areas such as decks and patios are in good condition. Regular maintenance can prevent costly repairs down the line and keep your property appealing. Stay Competitive : Review rental prices in your area to ensure you’re offering a fair and attractive rate. Properties priced correctly are more likely to rent quickly, reducing vacancy periods. Consider any recent upgrades or amenities that might justify a higher rent.
RTA Update, Bill update, rental update
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh December 17, 2024
Great news for renters and landlords alike! The government has recently passed new laws aimed at encouraging the development of more rental homes. These changes are designed to make renting better for tenants while supporting landlords to provide high-quality rental properties. Here’s what you need to know: What’s Changing? The new rules are focused on two key areas: Encouraging New Rentals The government is introducing policies to make it easier for landlords and investors to build more rental homes. This could mean: Reduced red tape for building new rental properties. Incentives for landlords to create long-term rental options. 2. Fairer Rules for Everyone The laws also aim to create a balanced environment for both tenants and landlords. This includes: Updates to tenancy agreements to provide clearer expectations. Stronger protections for tenants while ensuring landlords can manage their properties effectively. How Will This Impact Tenants? If you’re a tenant, these changes are good news! More rental properties in the market mean: More choices when looking for a home. Potentially lower rent as the competition among properties increases. Clearer and more secure tenancy agreements.
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh December 11, 2024
The Auckland rental market traditionally experiences a surge in activity during January and early February, making it the busiest time of the year for tenancy movements. With tenants gearing up for the year ahead, this period brings unique opportunities and challenges for both renters and property owners. Here’s what to expect and how to navigate the rental landscape during this bustling season. Why is Summer So Busy? Several factors contribute to the heightened activity in the rental market during this time: School Zones and Education Planning Families often prioritise school zones when deciding where to live. January is the ideal time for parents to secure rental properties close to desirable schools before the academic year begins. Auckland’s high-demand zones, such as those near Auckland Grammar or Epsom Girls' Grammar School, see increased competition as families seek to position their children for educational success. Job Changes and Relocations The new year often brings new job opportunities. Many tenants relocate closer to their workplaces to reduce commute times and improve work-life balance. Auckland’s bustling job hubs, such as the CBD, Albany, and Manukau, see increased demand for rental properties during this period. Summer Weather and Lifestyle Choices The warm summer months inspire tenants to reassess their living situations. Whether it’s upgrading to a home with outdoor spaces or moving closer to Auckland’s beaches, the season encourages change. The improved weather also makes moving house a more appealing prospect. Market Turnover and Property Availability With so many tenants moving, landlords often list properties during this time, increasing availability. This higher turnover benefits tenants, offering a wider range of properties to choose from, but also increases competition for the most desirable homes.
Pair of shoes on a rug with text home sweet home signifying tenant retention
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh September 12, 2024
We share some strategies for tenant retention, from offering lease incentives to maintaining open communication. Learn how to keep good tenants & reduce costs.
Solo traveller gets keys from a vacation rental owner for short-term property rental
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh September 12, 2024
Learn the pros and cons of short-term property rentals. We share benefits, challenges, and management tips to help you determine if it's right for you.
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh September 4, 2024
What is Renter's Insurance, and Do You Need It?
Landlord rights – Image of house keys on a wooden surface
By Tiri Raumati-Greenhalgh August 22, 2024
Discover your rights as a landlord with our comprehensive guide. Learn about legal obligations, rental agreements, eviction procedures, and more.
More Posts
Share by: